Portion of Philadelphia Salary History Ban Ruled Unconstitutional

Q.  Am I permitted to ask about an applicant’s salary history in Philadelphia?

A.  In a ruling that could provide a roadmap for challenging salary history bans in other jurisdictions, a Philadelphia federal judge issued an opinion on April 30 invalidating a major element of the Philadelphia salary history ordinance enacted by the city in January 2017. Judge Mitchell S. Goldberg held that the portion of the ordinance prohibiting an employer from inquiring about a prospective employee’s wage history is unconstitutional because it violates the First Amendment’s free speech clause. However, Judge Goldberg also held that the portion of the law prohibiting employers from relying on wage history to determine a salary for an employee did not implicate constitutional concerns. Philadelphia employers now find themselves in a difficult position: They are permitted to ask about an applicant’s salary history but cannot rely on that information.

For more information, please click here.

Tracey E. Diamond and Lee E. Tankle

 

Philadelphia Employers May Not Ask Wage History Questions Under New Ordinance

Q.  My company is based in Philadelphia.  We often set salaries for new employees based on the applicant’s wage history.  Are we still permitted to do this?

A.  Effective May 23, 2017, a new Philadelphia Ordinance makes it unlawful for employers in Philadelphia to inquire about a prospective employee’s wage history or require disclosure of wage history as a condition of employment.  The law was passed to encourage employers to base salary offers on the job responsibilities of the position sought, rather than on the applicant’s prior wages.  Employers will no longer be able to rely on the wage history of a prospective employee when determining the wages of that individual, unless the individual knowingly and willingly disclosed his or her wage history to the employer.

To ensure compliance with the Ordinance, employers who do business in Philadelphia should start thinking about revising their employment applications to delete any questions inquiring about an applicant’s wage history.  Recruiters, HR personnel and managers will need to be trained about the new law so that these individuals know not to ask wage-based questions during the interview process.  In addition, employers should consider revising their EEO policies to add wage history to the list of protected categories.

-Tracey E. Diamond